South Dakota v. Dole - Case Summary and Case Brief.
South Dakota v. Dole: Attachment of minimum drinking age to federal highway funds is constitutional because Congress may attach specific policy requirements for receipt of federal money. Fletcher v. Peck: State law rescinding land grants is unconstitutional because it impairs the obligation of contracts. Dartmouth College v. Woodward: State statute changing Dartmouth College is.
That statute allowed Elizabeth Dole, the Secretary of Transportation, to withhold a percentage of federal highway funds from states with a drinking age lower than twenty-one. South Dakota, which allowed nineteen-year-olds to purchase light beer, sued the Secretary. In Chapters 17 and 18 we will study New York v. United States (1992) and Printz.
Part I reviews South Dakota v. Dole and canvasses recent lower court decisions to illustrate just how toothless the Dole test has been in practice. Part II shows why the test is substantively and conceptually infirm. The upshot of this Part, of course, is that Dole should be abandoned. The prevailing scholarly assumption, however, is that it will not be. Indeed, it is precisely this assumption.
South Dakota v. Dole. STUDY. Flashcards. Learn. Write. Spell. Test. PLAY. Match. Gravity. Created by. taylorz6. Terms in this set (7) Background. In 1984, the United States Congress passed the National Minimum Drinking Age Act, which withheld 10%(1) of federal highway funding from states that did not maintain a minimum legal drinking age of 21. Holding. Congress may attach reasonable.
Case background and primary source documents concerning the Supreme Court case of South Dakota v. Dole. Dealing with the whether or not the Federal government can attach conditions to money given to states in areas where the Federal government has no enumerated power, this lesson asks students to evaluate the extent to which the Court's interpretation of the General Welfare clause and.
Marbury v. Madison (1803) The most important Supreme Court decision, it established judicial review. McCulloh v. Maryland (1819) This case set the precedent for federal courts to use judicial review to strike down unconstitutional Congressional legislation. South Dakota v. Dole (1987) The federal government enforced the 21 year old drinking age by taking away funds from state highway projects.
Tobacco Use In South Dakota Case Study. Tobacco use among teenagers and young adults in South Dakota is one of the most important public health issues in the state. The rates of both smoking and smokeless tobacco, known as “chew” or “spit,” in this age group are higher in South Dakota than in the nation. In fact, the Centers for Disease.